Mayfly vs Simple Analytics
Simple Analytics is an EU-hosted product with a free plan for hobby sites and pricing that follows your pageviews. Mayfly prices by websites and adds Search Console, Core Web Vitals and site audits.
Written for a founder or a small studio running several websites. Simple Analytics’s prices and features are as of November 2026, read from Simple Analytics’s own pages on , and every one links to its source. Where we couldn’t confirm something either way, we left it out rather than guess. Prices change, so check the source before you decide.
Which one fits
Choose Simple Analytics if…
- Your sites are hobby projects. The free plan covers 5 websites for one user, with one month of history and a required badge. Simple Analytics pricing (opens in a new tab)
- You need EU hosting. Data is stored in the EU, with primary infrastructure in the Netherlands. Simple Analytics pricing (opens in a new tab)
- You want AI tools on a free plan. Its MCP server works on every plan, including Free; Mayfly’s has no free plan to run on. Simple Analytics MCP (opens in a new tab)
- You want exports as Parquet files. Mayfly exports CSV and JSON only. Simple Analytics export docs (opens in a new tab)
- You value a long track record. Simple Analytics was established in 2018 in Amsterdam and is self-funded. About Simple Analytics (opens in a new tab)
Choose Mayfly if…
- You want Search Console data, real-user Core Web Vitals, a site audit with scheduled re-audits, before-and-after maintenance reports, branded client reports and an email when a site goes quiet in one place. Mayfly includes all of these on every plan; we couldn’t confirm whether Simple Analytics offers them.
- Your traffic is growing. Simple Analytics’ fee follows your pageview usage; Mayfly’s depends only on how many websites you run. Simple Analytics pricing (opens in a new tab)
What several sites cost
Simple Analytics’ self-serve plan starts at €20 a month for 100,000 pageviews and adds €20 a month for each extra user. We couldn’t confirm from its pricing page how many websites that plan holds, so we haven’t worked out a multi-site example. Simple Analytics pricing (opens in a new tab)
Side by side
Both columns as of November 2026. Each Simple Analytics entry links to the page it comes from.
| Topic | Mayfly | Simple Analytics | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price is based on | The number of websites. Solo $9 a month for up to 3, Founder $19 for up to 10, Studio $49 for up to 30. Traffic does not change the price. | Your pageview usage. Pay in euros, US dollars or pounds. | Simple Analytics pricing (opens in a new tab) |
| Entry price | Solo, $9 a month for up to 3 websites. | Free plan for hobby sites. Self-serve from €20 a month for 100,000 pageviews. Two months free with yearly billing. | Simple Analytics pricing (opens in a new tab) |
| Free plan | None. A 14-day trial instead. | 1 user, 5 websites, 1 month of history, badge required. | Simple Analytics pricing (opens in a new tab) |
| Free trial | 14 days, no card, up to 10 websites. | 14 days, no credit card. | Simple Analytics pricing (opens in a new tab) |
| Users | One login per account. Adding team members is not available yet. | Self-serve includes 1 user; each extra user is €20 a month. | Simple Analytics pricing (opens in a new tab) |
| Hosting | United States (US East). | Stored in the EU, primary infrastructure in the Netherlands. | Simple Analytics pricing (opens in a new tab) |
| Open source | No. Mayfly is hosted only; self-hosting is not offered. | A hosted product, not open source. The tracking scripts are open source. | Simple Analytics on open source (opens in a new tab)Simple Analytics script docs (opens in a new tab) |
| Goals and funnels | Goals and funnels on every plan. | Goals on plans that include them. Multi-step funnels. | Simple Analytics goals docs (opens in a new tab)Simple Analytics features (opens in a new tab) |
| Email reports | Weekly or monthly emails for one site to up to 10 people, including people without an account, who confirm before the first one. | Weekly or monthly, including to people who don’t use Simple Analytics. | Simple Analytics email reports (opens in a new tab) |
| Export and API | CSV downloads, a read API (JSON or CSV) and a read-only MCP server for AI tools, with keys per website and 30 requests a minute per site. | CSV, JSON, Parquet and more. The export API needs a plan that includes it. | Simple Analytics export docs (opens in a new tab) |
| AI tools | A read-only MCP server on every plan. | An MCP server on every plan, including Free. | Simple Analytics MCP (opens in a new tab) |
| White label | Branded maintenance report links on every plan, opened without an account. | Offered for enterprise and platform customers. | Simple Analytics white label (opens in a new tab) |
| Other alerts | An email when a site has no pageview for 24 hours, and one when an hour brings at least three times its usual traffic and 50 pageviews. A drop of more than 80% is flagged in the dashboard. Thresholds are fixed. | Email alerts before an SSL certificate expires. | Simple Analytics SSL alerts (opens in a new tab) |
| Track record | New. First released in September 2026. | Established in 2018 in Amsterdam. Self-funded. | About Simple Analytics (opens in a new tab) |
Simple Analytics is a trademark of its owner. Mayfly is not affiliated with or endorsed by Simple Analytics. If something here is out of date, write to us and we’ll correct it.
Other comparisons
See it with your own sites.
14 days free, no card, up to 10 websites. Or look around the demo first.