Mayfly vs Fathom
Fathom includes 50 websites on every plan and prices by pageviews. Mayfly prices by websites and adds Core Web Vitals, site audits and client reports.
Written for a founder or a small studio running several websites. Fathom’s prices and features are as of November 2026, read from Fathom’s own pages on , and every one links to its source. Where we couldn’t confirm something either way, we left it out rather than guess. Prices change, so check the source before you decide.
Which one fits
Choose Fathom if…
- You run many websites with modest traffic. Every Fathom plan includes at least 50 sites, from $15 a month for up to 100,000 pageviews. Fathom pricing (opens in a new tab)
- You want one scheduled email that covers several sites. Fathom’s email reports can combine sites; Mayfly sends one per site. Fathom features (opens in a new tab)
- You want to share full dashboards, publicly or behind a password, or per person. Fathom features (opens in a new tab)Fathom changelog, October 2026 (opens in a new tab)
- Many of your visitors are in the EU. Fathom strips their IP addresses in the EU before data reaches its US servers. Fathom data isolation (opens in a new tab)
- You value a long track record. Fathom was started in 2018 and is bootstrapped. About Fathom (opens in a new tab)
Choose Mayfly if…
- You want to try before paying. Mayfly’s trial is 14 days without a card; Fathom’s is 7 days with a card required. Fathom pricing (opens in a new tab)
- Your sites get a lot of traffic. Fathom prices by pageviews and custom events across all sites; Mayfly’s price depends only on how many websites you run. Fathom pricing (opens in a new tab)
- You want real-user Core Web Vitals, a site audit with scheduled re-audits, before-and-after maintenance reports, branded client report links and an email when a site goes quiet. Mayfly includes all of these; we couldn’t confirm whether Fathom offers them.
What several sites cost
Ten websites with 500,000 monthly pageviews between them: Fathom is $45 a month, Mayfly Founder is $19. Thirty websites with 100,000 pageviews between them: Fathom is $15 a month, Mayfly Studio is $49. Fathom pricing (opens in a new tab)
Side by side
Both columns as of November 2026. Each Fathom entry links to the page it comes from.
| Topic | Mayfly | Fathom | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price is based on | The number of websites. Solo $9 a month for up to 3, Founder $19 for up to 10, Studio $49 for up to 30. Traffic does not change the price. | Pageviews and custom events, shared across all sites. Every plan has the same features. | Fathom pricing (opens in a new tab) |
| Prices | Same as above. | $15 a month up to 100,000 pageviews, $25 up to 200,000, $45 up to 500,000, $60 up to 1 million. Two months free with yearly billing. | Fathom pricing (opens in a new tab) |
| Websites included | Up to 3, 10 or 30, by plan. | At least 50 on every plan. More in packs of 50 for $10 a month. | Fathom pricing (opens in a new tab) |
| Free trial | 14 days, no card, up to 10 websites. | 7 days, card required. No free plan. | Fathom pricing (opens in a new tab) |
| Team members | One login per account. Adding team members is not available yet. | The account holder is the only person who can log in; Fathom says user accounts are in progress. | Fathom shared dashboards (opens in a new tab) |
| Data retention | Raw events for 25 months, daily totals for 37 months. | Full analytics history while subscribed. | Fathom pricing (opens in a new tab) |
| Hosting | United States (US East). | Anonymised data is stored on US servers; EU visitors’ IP addresses are removed in the EU first. | Fathom data isolation (opens in a new tab) |
| Self-hosting | No. Mayfly is hosted only; self-hosting is not offered. | No. Fathom is a hosted product. | Fathom features (opens in a new tab) |
| Search Console | Yes. A read-only import of queries, pages, clicks, impressions and positions. | Yes: search terms, clicks and impressions. | Fathom features (opens in a new tab) |
| Revenue | Revenue sent with a custom event, totalled per goal and filterable by the visit’s source. No payment-provider integration attributes payments to visits. | Send a value with an event and choose its currency. | Fathom features (opens in a new tab) |
| Sharing | A public link to seven days of daily uniques and pageviews, nothing more. | Public or password-protected dashboards. Per-person share links, up to 100 per site. | Fathom features (opens in a new tab)Fathom changelog, October 2026 (opens in a new tab) |
| Client reports | Branded maintenance report links on every plan, opened without an account. Weekly or monthly emails for one site to up to 10 people, including people without an account, who confirm before the first one. | Scheduled weekly or monthly emails to you, colleagues or clients, for one or several sites. | Fathom features (opens in a new tab) |
| All your sites in one view | All sites: every website side by side, sorted by the biggest change, with silent sites flagged. | An all-sites view. | Fathom features (opens in a new tab) |
| API and export | CSV downloads, a read API (JSON or CSV) and a read-only MCP server for AI tools, with keys per website and 30 requests a minute per site. | CSV downloads and an API. | Fathom features (opens in a new tab) |
| AI assistant | None. | Luna, an assistant inside the dashboard, added in October 2026. | Fathom changelog, Luna (opens in a new tab) |
| Track record | New. First released in September 2026. | Started in 2018. Bootstrapped, with no investors. | About Fathom (opens in a new tab) |
Fathom is a trademark of its owner. Mayfly is not affiliated with or endorsed by Fathom. If something here is out of date, write to us and we’ll correct it.
Other comparisons
See it with your own sites.
14 days free, no card, up to 10 websites. Or look around the demo first.